Will your homeowners insurance cover fence repair?

When a fence gets damaged, it’s natural to wonder whether your homeowners insurance will pay to fix it. The short answer: sometimes yes, sometimes no. It all depends on how the damage happened and what your policy says.

Here’s what you need to know.

What Does “Fence Coverage” Mean?

Most homeowners insurance policies include a section called Other Structures (often “Coverage B”). This part covers detached structures on your property — like fences, sheds, detached garages, etc. American Family Insurance+3Travelers+3Progressive+3

So, when your fence is damaged, the insurance question often comes down to:

• Was it damaged by a cause your policy covers (“a peril”)?

• Was the fence maintained properly?

• Does the cost of repair exceed your deductible or make a claim worthwhile?

  
  

When Insurance Will Cover Fence Repair

Here are the situations where your homeowners insurance usually does cover fence repair:

• A tree falls on the fence because of a storm or wind. If it wasn’t due to neglect. Progressive+2Kin+2

• Windstorm or hail damages the fence. Hippo+2ValuePenguin+2

• Vandalism damages the fence (you might need a police report). Progressive+1

• A car crashes into your fence (or someone else’s car, you can claim against their driver or your home policy). Hippo+1

  
  

In short: If the damage was sudden, accidental, unexpected, and due to a cause the policy covers — you have a good chance.

When Insurance Won’t Cover Fence Repair

And here are common situations where your fence damage likely won’t be covered:

• Wear and tear: rotting wood, rusted metal, general aging of the fence. Travelers+1

• Lack of maintenance: if the fence failed because you didn’t maintain it (e.g., untreated wood, neglected posts). Lemonade+1

• Damage from floods or earthquakes: many standard homeowner policies exclude these unless you’ve added special coverage. Progressive+1

• Damage due to pests, decay, or inherent defects in construction. Lemonade

So even if your fence is damaged, if the cause is something the insurer considers “preventable” or “maintenance-related,” your claim could be denied.

Key Policy Details to Check

Before you assume your fence is covered, check these specifics in your policy:

• Deductible: You’ll likely need to cover the deductible before insurance pays. If repair cost < deductible, you may end up paying it yourself. ValuePenguin

• Coverage limit for other structures: Many policies limit “other structures” to a percentage of your home’s dwelling coverage (often around 10%). Travelers+1

• Definition of “covered peril”: What events are covered (wind, fire, vandalism, etc.) and what’s excluded.

• Material / condition of the fence: Some insurers differentiate by material and condition (wood vs vinyl, new vs old) when calculating payout. SageSure

• Ownership / boundary issues: Ensure you actually “own” the fence (not your neighbor, HOA responsibility, etc.). Ownership issues can complicate claims. SageSure

• 
  

Steps to Take if Your Fence Is Damaged

Here’s a clear path you can follow to increase your chance of getting insurance to pay:

1. Take photos/videos of the damage as soon as it’s safe.

2. Record exactly how it happened (storm, falling tree, vehicle crash, etc.).

3. Get a repair estimate from a qualified contractor.

4. Review your insurance policy: check the deductible, other structures limit, covered events.

5. Contact your insurance agent/claim department and ask whether the damage is likely covered under your policy.

6. If you file a claim: provide photos, estimate, and any police report (for vandalism or car crash).

7. Do temporary repairs if needed to prevent further damage (but keep documentation of original damage).

8. Understand whether the payout will be based on actual cash value (value minus depreciation) or replacement cost. Many claims settle at actual cash value for fences, depending on material/age. TCS Insurance Brokers+1

   
   

Example Scenarios

• Storm damage: A strong windstorm blows over part of your wooden fence. Your homeowner policy lists windstorm as a covered peril. The fence had been maintained. Likely covered.

• Wear and tear: Your fence has rotted posts and eventually collapses. The cause: age and lack of maintenance. Not covered.

• Neighbor’s tree falls: A healthy tree from your neighbor’s yard falls during a thunderstorm and destroys your fence. Your policy may cover it and then subrogate against your neighbor/neigh­bor’s insurance. Travelers+1

• Flood damage: A flood washes out your fence. If your policy excludes flood damage (which many do), you’ll need special flood insurance. Not covered by standard homeowner policy. Progressive+1

  
  

Bottom Line

Yes — your homeowners insurance can pay for fence repair, but only if the damage comes from a covered event and you meet the policy criteria. And no — it won’t cover damage caused by neglect, wear and tear, or excluded perils like floods or earthquakes (unless you added those).

Before you file a claim, check your policy, get your facts in order (photos, estimate), and ask your agent if the cost vs deductible makes sense. Sometimes, paying out of pocket for a small fence repair may be simpler than filing a claim and possibly affecting your premium.